Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-14 Sallie Tomato 1 views

Emma vs Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits: Which Should You Sew?

Emma vs Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits: Which Should You Sew?

Compare the Emma and Lisa shoulder bag sewing kits by finished size, what's included, and fabric needs, so you can pick the kit that fits your stash and skill level.

Two intermediate kits, two different starting points

Both the Emma Shoulder Bag Kit and the Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits are coordinated sewing kits rated at pattern difficulty 3 Intermediate, and both are designed around Sallie Tomato shoulder bag patterns. The real decision comes down to what you already have on your shelf and how you want to spend your sewing time. The Emma kit asks you to supply the main, accent, and lining fabrics from your stash, while the Lisa kit includes its main fabric and lining but requires the Lisa Pattern PDF separately.

Neither kit is a beginner's first project in the sense of a simple tote. The intermediate rating means you should be comfortable with zippers, layered construction, and hardware installation before you start. If you are still building those skills, a simpler bag kit may serve you better; if you have made a few bags, both of these are reasonable next steps.

What each kit actually gives you

  • Emma Shoulder Bag Kit: Emma Shoulder Bag Kit includes the Emma Paper Pattern, 36" x 19" Interfacing, 12" x 58" Sew-In Foam, a 26" #5 Zipper in Brown/Gunmetal, gunmetal hardware, two zipper pulls, a 1" Style 1 Basic Hardware Kit, zipper cord end, handmade label, and bag feet. The paper pattern and structural supplies are in the box, so the Emma kit is closer to a complete project once you add fabric.
    Emma Shoulder Bag Kit
    Emma Shoulder Bag Kit
  • Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits: Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits include 23" x 25" main fabric, 12" x 42" lining, 18" x 19" fusible woven interfacing, 5" x 20" heavy stabilizer, an 18" #5 zipper, hardware, zipper pulls, 1/2" D-rings, 1" swivel hooks, 1" slider buckle, 1/2" bag feet, and a handmade label. The Lisa kit supplies the exterior and interior fabric, so you are not digging through your stash for the main material.
    Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits
    Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits

Finished size: a compact shoulder bag vs a roomier one

The Lisa bag finishes at 8-1/2" wide, 6" high, and 3" deep (21.6cm wide, 15.2cm high, and 7.6cm deep). The Emma bag finishes at 10-1/4" wide, 12-1/2" high, and 5" deep. That is a meaningful difference in carrying capacity: the Emma is taller and deeper, while the Lisa is a smaller, more compact shoulder bag.

If you want a bag for a phone, wallet, keys, and a few small extras, the Lisa size is practical. If you routinely carry a tablet, a small notebook, or more than the bare essentials, the Emma's extra height and depth give you more room.

  • Lisa Shoulder Bag: 8-1/2" wide x 6" high x 3" deep; zipper top closure, boxed sides, interior slip pocket, adjustable straps from main fabric or webbing.
  • Emma Shoulder Bag: 10-1/4" wide x 12-1/2" high x 5" deep; top zipper closure, exterior slip pockets, shoulder strap, sturdy base, interior slip and zipper pockets.

Fabric: bring your stash or open the box

The Emma kit is built around using your own fabric. The record lists 14" x 42" main fabric, 18" x 42" accent fabric, and 23" x 42" lining as "None (use your stash)," and to complete the bag you need 12" x 42" main fabric, 45" x 42" lining, and 18" x 42" accent fabric. The kit does include an 18" x 25" contrast fabric in Hazelnut Pebble. The product photo shows Windham Botanical Macadamia-Tulip main and accent fabric, which is not included. If you enjoy picking fabrics and already have a stash, this is a feature; if you want everything coordinated for you, it is extra work.

The Lisa kit takes the opposite approach. It includes 23" x 25" main fabric in your chosen colorway, 12" x 42" lining, and coordinated hardware and zipper pulls. The available variants are Stone Rugged Leather and Cherries Cork, with a Rustic Robin Egg Cork option listed in the kit details. One important limitation: webbings shown on bag samples are not included in the kits, so plan to supply webbing or make straps from the main fabric. The Lisa Pattern is also a downloadable PDF only and is not included in the kit.

Pattern and hardware details worth checking before you buy

  • Emma Shoulder Bag Kit: Emma hardware color may vary from the photo, and the kit includes a 1" Style 1 Basic Hardware Kit. If exact hardware color matters to your finished bag, confirm what is currently shipping before you commit.
  • Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits: Lisa kits include a 1/2" D-rings, 1" swivel hooks, and a 1" slider buckle, with hardware color matched to the colorway (Gunmetal, Rose Gold, or Nickel). The Lisa kit coordinates hardware to the fabric choice, which reduces the guesswork of matching metals.

Which kit fits your next project?

Choose the Emma Shoulder Bag Kit if you want a larger finished bag, you already have suitable main, accent, and lining fabrics, and you prefer a printed pattern in the box. The Emma kit's included foam and interfacing support its structured, sturdy-base construction, and the exterior slip pockets add everyday utility.

Choose the Lisa Shoulder Bag Kits if you want a compact shoulder bag and would rather have the main fabric and lining selected for you. Be prepared to buy the Lisa Pattern PDF separately and to supply webbing if you want webbing straps. Both kits are intermediate-level projects, so the deciding factors are size, fabric preference, and whether you want a paper pattern or a PDF.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile